Late in 2007, I was standing in an oil and gas auction, bidding and buying properties that we had researched as they came up within our price range. As the auction progressed, I was speaking with a long time oil operator who was in the process of buying and selling properties at the same auction. As the lots sold, I was buying in the 25% to 30% annual return range. As we spoke of the lots, he would look at his employees and ask them, “Why didn’t we bid on that lot?, Paul just bought it for a huge return”. This went on for more than an hour and you could see the frustration in his face as I bought lot after lot for a greater than 20% annual cash return.
The reason that his team did not bid on the properties that I was buying was that he was an old time oil man with definite ideas about the properties he wanted to own. His mind was closed to a majority of the marketplace, including the niche where I was buying. He wanted to operate the properties, he wanted greater than 25% interest in the properties, and on and on. His focus was extremely narrow, for such a broad investment world.
On the other hand, our focus was on another, broader, less popular niche…one that we had identified as a true value in the world of oil and gas production.
The psyche of 90% of oil and gas operators is that they want to call the shots. They don’t want someone else making decisions without their input. This industry bias creates a huge niche in which we can invest and make exceptional profits.
Our niche is generally known as the bastard of the oil and gas business. Because of the psychological stance in the oil and gas business, our niche is not very competitive and the values are ripe for the taking.
One of our managed funds has averaged over 25% annual cash returns for the past 4 years (yes…even during 2008). In 2009, we are up over 11% and it is only July and commodity prices are on the rise.
Another example of where big funds pass on true value every day is highlighted by an experience that I had last year with a New York based fund manager.
I was pitching 3 years of research we had conducted in the mini-storage marketplace in a large Texas marketplace. We had identified every competitor, photographed their property, conducted due diligence and identified their competitive set and details. During this research, we had uncovered 5 exceptional acquisitions and 15 well supported locations to build self storages in this metropolis. After an hour of discussion with some underlings, they were all ready to move forward with our $50,000,000 program. Just then, the chief investment officer came into the room, the team told him what they wanted to do….he looked at them like they were idiots. He said ‘Have you seen the national self storage numbers’, they are terrible. We don’t want to invest in that sector.
The underlings were dumbfounded. They talked about the research, the proposal, the low overhead…to a person, they were ready to invest $50,000,000 of their funds money into our deal. After 15 minutes of discussion, the Chief Investment Officer stood firm with his bias and told the team that he did not want to do the deal and did not want to hear any more about it. He said he would rather leave his money in the bank at a 1% return than invest in the Texas economy. Talk about an idiot.
Because of national numbers that had absolutely nothing to do with the local economy in our area of research, this intelligent manager let numbers posted by publically run companies with exteme overhead burdens and layers of management create a bias in his mind. Because of these numbers, this savvy Chief Investment Officer passed on a deal that would have made him secure 25%+ annual returns for decades to come.
His narrow focus and lack of ability to recognize quaility research cost him a great relationship.
At Farpoint, our investments are opportunistic, niche plays that are more often than not “CONTRARIAN” to the overall marketplace. This is where we make money. And our investors support this approach.
We operate on the adage that “When everyone else says sell, we are buying.” This philosophy has made us and our partners millions of dollars over the past decades and we will continue to execute on this philosophy.
During the economic downturn on the 1980’s, given the capital, I could have purchased real property in the Dallas area for $.01 on the dollar. No one was buying and the RTC was selling a huge portfolio at the deepest discounts ever seen. Even today, those properties are worth a fortune and bought for pennies.
See what we are up to here: http://www.farpointadvisors.com
See what our energy arm is doing: http://www.oilstatestrading.com
Buy a copy of my newest book: http://www.winningwithprivateequity.us
Email me with your best or worst ever investment idea. If it tells a story, I may use it in my next book. paul@farpointadvisors.com
Thanks for Reading…
Paul Anthony Thomas